| ALL-AHA First Team |
| F: Felix Trudeau, SR, Sacred Heart |
| F: Jack Stockfish, SR, Holy Cross |
| F: Jake Black, SR, Bentley |
| D: Chris Hedden, SR, Air Force |
| D: Mikey Adamson, SR, Sacred Heart |
| G: JJ Cataldo, SO, Army West Point |
|
| ALL-AHA Second Team |
| F: Tanner Klimpke, JR, Robert Morris |
| F: Jack Ivey, SO, Army West Point |
| F: Stephen Castagna, SR, Bentley |
| D: Mack Oliphant, SR, Holy Cross |
| D: Dominic Elliott, SO, Robert Morris |
| G: Jakub Krbecek, SO, RIT |
|
| ALL-AHA Third Team |
| F: Grant Porter, SR, Canisius |
| F: Walter Zacher, JR, Canisius |
| F: Killian Kiecker-Olson, SR, Canisius |
| D: Jack Dalton, JR, Bentley |
| D: Nolan Cunningham, JR, Air Force |
| G: Dominik Wasik, JR, Air Force |
|
| AHA All-Rookie Team |
| F: Zach Wigle, FR, RIT |
| F: Evan Konyen, FR, RIT |
| F: Maxim Muranov, FR, Niagara |
| D: FJ Buteau, FR, Canisius |
| D: John Babcock, FR, Robert Morris |
| G: Lukas Swedin, FR, Bentley |